Audio Version: Audio player to be added by SCN before publication.
A child in the next room asks the speaker a question, and it answers. Then you remember the other part: depending on the settings, it may also keep a copy of what your child said. That is a small detail worth checking before the next round of dinosaur facts.
The Alexa privacy settings that decide this are not hidden, exactly. They are just easy to never open. What follows is what gets saved, how three settlements changed the conversation, and what to check tonight if a child in your house talks to a speaker.
Quick Review
- Alexa may save voice recordings and transcripts, and Amazon says parents can review and delete them.
- New UK research separates problems with smart products from harms people say they experienced.
- Three settlements involving voice assistant privacy total $188 million, without admissions of wrongdoing.
- You can review Alexa’s data settings tonight and choose how long recordings are kept.
What A Smart Speaker Actually Saves About Your Child
When a child speaks to Alexa, there may be a saved audio recording and a written transcript associated with the request. Amazon says parents can review, hear, and delete recordings and transcripts, and choose whether they are saved. What is retained depends on the available privacy settings and choices for the account.
That is different from saying every sound in the room is necessarily saved. It is also different from a device responding unexpectedly. A glitch can prompt a useful settings check, but by itself it does not establish that a recording was stored, accessed by someone else, or caused harm.
Amazon says it retains children’s voice recordings until a parent chooses to delete them, so parents can see how children use Alexa and so the company can provide and improve its services. That is the direct answer to why a child’s voice might remain on a server: Amazon describes retention as useful both to families and to its service.
What The New Research Found About Harm
On November 17, 2026, the UK’s Office for Product Safety and Standards published research prepared by Professor Magda Osman at the University of Cambridge. Its two studies surveyed 1,464 UK adults in July and August 2025, then 497 adults in March 2026, about internet-connected products including voice assistants, smart TVs, connected toys, and smart baby monitors.
Smart speakers were the most commonly owned product in both studies, reported by 50% of the first sample and 63.4% of the second. In Study 2, 98% of participants described at least one issue with the smart product they reported on. Among people who had a problem, 62% said it had never caused them harm. Of the 38% who did report harm, psychological harm was most common, at 19%, followed by financial harm.
For smart speakers specifically, 72% reported no harm and 17% psychological harm. For comparison, 44% of people reporting on smart doorbells said they experienced no harm, while 29% reported psychological harm. The most selected response to what regulators should do was collect more evidence, chosen by 43%, ahead of removing products from the market, at 21%.
The findings also suggest people with more experience of smart products judge risks lower than those with less experience. Familiarity can make a device feel ordinary, but it is not the same as safety. The research supports a measured approach: notice the problem, check what happened, and look for evidence rather than assuming either that harm occurred or that nothing matters.
Three Settlements, 188 Million Dollars, No Admission Of Wrongdoing
In January 2025, Apple agreed to pay $95 million to settle a Siri privacy class action, without admitting wrongdoing. Google moved to settle a Google Assistant class action for $68 million, as reported by The Verge on January 26, 2026. The case followed a 2019 report that human contractors listened to recordings captured when devices were triggered by something other than “Ok Google”; contractors recalled hearing personal information and private conversations, including from children who were not supposed to be using the device. Google denies wrongdoing as part of the proposed settlement. If approved, payments would range from $18 to $56 for qualifying device buyers and $2 to $10 for some users or household members.
Amazon paid $25 million in 2023 to settle FTC and DOJ allegations about children’s Alexa voice recordings. Amazon denied violating the law. Together, the Apple, Google, and Amazon amounts total $188 million. These settlements are not a finding that any company broke the law.
98% of people in a new UK study described a problem with their smart device. Only 38% said it ever caused them harm.
Know a parent who needs this? Send it to them.
Alexa Privacy Settings: What To Change Tonight
Amazon describes several privacy controls parents can use. In the Alexa app, go to Alexa Privacy and manage your Alexa data. Review saved recordings and transcripts, then choose automatic deletion after three months rather than 18 months or never, or choose not to save recordings at all.
You can also delete a recording by voice or clear recordings by date range or by device. Check Drop In and turn it off on any device in a child’s room. Use Amazon Kids profiles on devices children use, and use the physical microphone off button when nobody is using the device.
Settings can help, but they are not a guarantee. SCN explains why parental controls can fail and why a control you cannot verify is not a safeguard you can count on. After changing a setting, check that it matches what you intended.

The Quieter Problem: Your Child's Voice As Training Data
The harm parents may fear is a stranger in the speaker. The routine concern is quieter: an archive of a child’s voice retained to support product improvement. The difference between the two is often a setting most families never open.
A speaker that a five-year-old uses for dinosaur facts may, by age ten, have heard years of family conversation. No notice arrives when the room stops feeling like a place where that level of retention is fine. Revisit the decision as your child grows.
Research funded through the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, led by Dr. Ajay Shrestha at Vancouver Island University, audited Google Home, Alexa, and Siri and examined young people’s experiences. It included five focus groups with 26 young people and a survey with 469 usable responses from people aged 16 to 24. Its central finding: young people were more likely to protect their privacy when controls were easy to locate, understand, use, and confirm. That applies to a 45-year-old parent, too. If a setting is hard to find or unclear, it is harder to use with confidence.

What To Do When The Speaker Is A Gift This Season
A smart speaker is one of the most common gifts of the season, so make the privacy conversation before the box is opened, not after. Decide together where it will live, whether it should save recordings, and who will review its settings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does A Smart Speaker Record Everything It Hears?
A saved request is not the same as a complete recording of everything said in the room. Check the device’s privacy controls to see what recordings and transcripts are saved and what choices are available.
Can I Delete My Child's Voice Recordings?
Amazon says parents can delete recordings and transcripts in the Alexa app or on the Alexa Privacy page, including by voice, date range, or device. You can also choose not to save recordings or set automatic deletion.
Should A Smart Speaker Go In A Child's Bedroom?
A shared space makes it easier to review how the device is used and to manage its settings. If you do place one in a child’s room, check Drop In, use an Amazon Kids profile, and choose the retention settings that fit your family.
Would you keep a smart speaker in a shared room or in your child’s bedroom? Share your thoughts in the comments.
Join the SCN newsletter for practical guidance on children’s digital well-being and emerging technology.
If this helped, share it with another parent and follow Secure Children's Network on Facebook, X and LinkedIn for safety alerts.
Author: Janice Robinson-Celeste
Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.