Quick Review

• “Bell to bell” generally means students cannot access personal devices from the start of the school day until dismissal.
• Boston Public Schools has proposed a broader policy that would include personal phones, laptops, and smartwatches, but the proposal still needs a School Committee vote.
• Students’ concerns about reaching family during an emergency deserve clear answers from schools.
• Ask about emergency communication, device storage, and exceptions for medical needs or disability accommodations before the policy takes effect.

Your child may be used to checking a phone between classes, listening to music at lunch, or texting you after school. As more schools move toward all-day restrictions, it helps to know what “phone-free” means in your district, and how you and your child can prepare.

Audio: Audio version coming soon.

What’s Changing In Schools

On October 15, Boston Public Schools officials proposed a bell-to-bell restriction on personal electronic devices, including cellphones, laptops, and smartwatches. Under the proposal, devices would be turned off and kept inaccessible during the school day. The policy could begin in September 2027, but it is not yet approved: a School Committee vote is planned for January, and the district is still developing implementation guidance. You can read the details in Boston.com’s report on the proposal.

Other policies are already in effect. Montgomery County Public Schools in Maryland has introduced its “No Cell, Bell to Bell” approach. Students have raised concerns about contacting parents in emergencies, according to Capital News Service reporting. In Indiana, statewide Senate Enrolled Act 78 restricts wireless communication devices during the school day, with exceptions that include medical needs and qualifying IEP or Section 504 plans. Devices covered can include phones, smartwatches, tablets, laptops, wireless headphones, and gaming devices; implementation details may vary by school.

Massachusetts is also supporting school and student well-being initiatives. Governor Maura Healey announced $1.75 million in grants for safe social media use and student mental health through a state initiative. That is separate from the phone-free school grants announced earlier.

What “Bell To Bell” May Mean For Your Child

A bell-to-bell policy usually covers more than class time. Depending on the district’s written rules, students may be asked to keep devices powered off and stored away during lunch, passing periods, study halls, and other parts of the school day.

Policies are not identical. Boston’s proposal, for example, refers to personal electronic devices, while a school may still provide or permit school-issued technology for learning. Before making assumptions, ask what counts as a personal device, where it must be stored, and whether your child can access it during breaks or after dismissal.

Ask Your School These Questions

A useful policy should explain not only what students cannot do, but also how families and staff can respond to everyday needs and emergencies. Contact the school or district and ask:

• What devices are covered? Are smartwatches, wireless headphones, and personal laptops included? How does the rule distinguish personal from school-issued devices?
• Where will devices be stored? Must they stay in a backpack, locker, classroom pouch, or designated secure location? Who is responsible for them?
• How can I reach my child during the day? Which office number, attendance line, portal, or other school-managed channel should I use?
• How will the school contact families during an emergency? Ask how urgent updates will be shared and where families should go for verified information.
• What is the reunification plan? If students need to leave campus or be picked up, how will the school tell caregivers where to go and when?
• What exceptions are available? Ask how families request accommodations for a medical need, an IEP, or a Section 504 plan, and whom to contact if a plan needs updating.
• How are urgent student concerns handled? Find out how a student can reach a trusted adult, report a problem, or get help without using a personal device.

Policies and legal requirements differ by location. For Indiana’s exceptions, review the official SEA 78 bill information and ask your school how they are applied locally. If your child has a health or disability-related need, communicate with the appropriate school staff early so the process is clear before an issue comes up.

Address The Emergency Concern Directly

Students’ worry about contacting family is worth taking seriously. The answer should not be a vague “don’t worry”; it should be a plan your child can explain back to you.

Ask the school to clarify how students can get staff support, how families can contact the main office, and how emergency messages will reach caregivers. Confirm that your contact information and approved pickup list are current. Agree on a simple family routine, too: if plans change during the school day, you will contact the school rather than relying on your child to check a phone.

Reassure your child that a phone restriction does not mean they are on their own. Identify a teacher, counselor, office staff member, or other trusted adult they can approach if they feel unsafe, unwell, or uncertain. SCN’s parent resources and educator resources can support families and school communities as they build clear, practical safety routines.

What The Research Does, and Doesn’t, Say

There is a reasonable case for reducing classroom distraction. In 2025, the National Center for Education Statistics reported that 53% of public school leaders said cellphone use negatively affected academic performance, 72% reported a negative effect on students’ mental health, and 73% reported a negative effect on attention span. These are school leaders’ views, not proof that a ban alone causes better grades or improved mental health. The NCES report also found that many schools already restrict phone use during class.

A phone-free school day may help create more opportunities to focus, talk with peers, and take part in class. But outcomes depend on implementation, support, and the needs of individual students. Clear communication, consistent expectations, and appropriate accommodations matter. A device rule works best as one part of a broader approach to student well-being, not as a substitute for adult support or sound emergency procedures.

Help Your Child Prepare

Before a new rule starts, talk through what a typical school day will look like. Practice the steps your child can take if plans change or they need help:

• Memorize or carry the school’s main office number in an approved way.
• Know which trusted adults to approach and where to find them.
• Agree on how you will handle schedule changes, pickup, or an urgent family message.
• Check that any needed accommodation has been discussed with the school.
• Make device storage part of the morning routine, so the rule does not become a daily surprise.

Keep the conversation practical and calm. You can acknowledge that being separated from a phone may feel unfamiliar while helping your child understand where support will come from.

Five Questions To Take To Your School

Know a parent who needs this? Send it to them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does A Bell-To-Bell Ban Mean My Child Can Never Use A Phone At School?

Usually, it means personal devices are inaccessible during the defined school day, not necessarily that a child cannot bring one to campus. Check the written policy for storage, permitted use before or after school, and exceptions.

Can My Child Contact Me In An Emergency?

Ask your school how students reach staff and how families are contacted. Confirm the main office number and emergency communication process. Your child should know which adults to approach if they need immediate help.

Can A Student Use A Phone For A Medical Need Or Disability Accommodation?

Some laws and school policies provide exceptions for medical needs or qualifying disability-related accommodations. Requirements differ. Contact the school about your child’s specific needs and ask how to document and implement an exception.

Does Research Prove Phone Bans Improve Mental Health?

No single statistic proves that a school phone ban will improve an individual student’s mental health. NCES data reflect school leaders’ reported concerns about phone use; they do not establish that bans by themselves cause better outcomes. Schools and families should look for clear policies paired with appropriate student support.

Join A Shared Commitment To Student Safety

A thoughtful school phone policy should make expectations clear while ensuring students can reach trusted adults and families know what to do when plans change. Join the Secure Children’s Network newsletter through SCN’s website for practical resources and updates on children’s digital well-being.

What is the most important question you want your school to answer about its phone policy?

If this helped, share it with another parent and follow Secure Children's Network on Facebook, X and LinkedIn for safety alerts.