Audio Version: Audio player to be added by SCN before publication.
It is 7:40 on a weeknight, the popcorn bowl is empty, and the television has just recognized the cartoon your child is watching. Smart TV privacy is rarely on a parent’s mind at that moment, yet the same technology that suggests the next episode can report what played to a tracking provider, and researchers found some sets kept doing it after the switch was turned off.
Quick Review
- Automatic content recognition, or ACR, can identify what is playing on a TV and send snapshots or digital fingerprints to a tracking provider.
- Researchers found that a kids’ app was among the places where tracking was active, raising questions about children’s privacy.
- An opt-out is not a universal switch: its effect differed across TV systems and services.
- A 10-minute settings check can help, but disconnecting the TV and using an external streaming device is the researchers’ strongest across-brand option.
Why Smart TV Privacy Is A Parenting Issue Now
A TV can recognize what is on screen by taking short audio or video snapshots, or by creating fingerprints from them. Those fingerprints are sent over the internet to a provider, which can compare them with known content. Viewing habits may then be used for targeted ads or shared with other companies. According to the Watching the Watchers study, 82% of U.S. households have a smart TV that can do this.
That makes the television part of your child’s connected environment, even if they never sign into a social app or use a phone. As SCN has explained in its guide to where parental controls can fall short, settings on a device or app do not necessarily cover the television’s own operating system.
What The Researchers Tested
Northeastern University researchers tested 12 TVs from 10 manufacturers, covering eight operating systems and about 95% of the U.S. smart TV market. They ran 10 viewing scenarios on each TV, with tracking on and after opting out, for 5,943 automated experiments.
Scenarios included antenna broadcasts, built-in and third-party streaming services, HDMI input, screen mirroring and an idle TV home screen. The team checked when ACR-related traffic appeared and whether the settings changed it.
The researchers say most traffic was encrypted, so for most systems they inferred tracking from the traffic’s behavior rather than reading its contents. VIDAA was an exception because its ACR traffic was unencrypted.

Which Televisions Kept Tracking And Which Stopped
Antenna broadcasts were tracked on every operating system the researchers could analyze. They found no TV tracked Netflix or YouTube. Tubi, a free ad-supported service, was tracked on Samsung’s Tizen, Google TV on a Sony set and VIDAA. HDMI input was tracked on five of seven systems, but not on Roku or Vizio’s SmartCast.
After opting out, ACR tracking fully stopped on only four tested systems: LG webOS, Google TV on Sony, VIDAA and Amazon Fire TV OS. Results differed elsewhere:
- Samsung: Traffic consistent with tracking continued in 41 of 60 antenna runs, 18 of 30 HDMI runs and 6 of 30 Tubi runs. It appeared in all 30 opted-out runs of Samsung’s built-in streaming service.
- Roku: The opt-out did not apply to Roku’s own streaming service. TCL explains this in its settings menu; Roku TVs do not.
- Vizio: The setting had no observable effect on traffic to the endpoint researchers identified as its tracking endpoint. All opted-out runs still sent traffic to it.
Vizio’s position matters here. The researchers observed encrypted traffic and said their finding was based on its behavior, not on reading its contents. Vizio spokesperson Mischa Dunton told The Verge: “The encrypted traffic researchers observed is not ACR data, but rather routine operational data used to support the Vizio experience.” That is Vizio’s response, reported by The Verge.
A smart TV can identify what is playing on screen, and in one study the opt-out fully worked on only four of the eight systems tested.
Know a parent who needs this? Send it to them.
Why Your Child’s Shows Are Not Exempt
The researchers saw tracking active in apps including VIDAA Kids. They say the findings raise concerns under the U.S. children’s privacy law, COPPA. The study does not establish that a company broke the law; it identifies a question for families and policymakers.
On VIDAA, tracking messages traveled unencrypted to servers operated by Unruly. Each carried a permanent device identifier that cannot be reset, along with details such as the time zone, app name, input, channel and an audio fingerprint. The servers returned content categories including Religious, Health and Medicine, and Political.
Researchers also found that one server made more than 57 million detection results from over 1 million unique TVs readable without a login. VIDAA fixed the login issue after the researchers reported it, but messages are still sent unencrypted. They also demonstrated that a previously sent message could be replayed to a TV, which could allow an attacker to push fake or harmful messages. They did not attempt this beyond their ethical testing.
The Ten-Minute Family Check
Menu names vary by model, but you can start with these steps:
- Find the tracking setting. Look in the TV’s privacy, viewing information or advertising menus for ACR or viewing data. Turn it off if you do not want that feature enabled.
- Check the TV’s own streaming app. The opt-out may not cover a built-in service. Roku’s opt-out, for example, does not apply to its own streaming service.
- Review voice and audio settings separately. These are different from ACR. If you use Google TV, check whether usage and diagnostics sharing, personalized recommendations and ads, and Google Account Web and App Activity tracking were left on during setup.
- Decide whether the TV needs its own internet connection. The researchers recommend disconnecting the set and streaming through an external device. It is the one step they suggest that works across every brand they tested. It stops transmission while the TV is offline, though companies’ responses differ on whether some data may be held locally and sent when the connection returns. LG says offline voice-recognition data is not stored for later upload.
- Confirm the change. A setting you cannot verify is not much protection. SCN’s guide to checking parental-control settings explains why it helps to review what the control actually covers.
What The Television Companies Told Us
In a separate report, The Verge put 17 yes-or-no questions to 11 companies. Amazon, Apple, Google, LG, Roku, Samsung and TCL responded; Hisense did not respond to five attempts, and Panasonic, Sony and Vizio did not answer.
The companies described different defaults. Google said usage and diagnostics sharing, personalized recommendations and ads, and Google Account Web and App Activity tracking are enabled by default unless users opt out. Samsung said its viewing information service, including ACR, is off by default and must be switched on; it said disabling it deletes previously collected tracking data from its servers. LG said ACR is off by default and optional. Roku said its Smart TV Experience feature is off by default in the U.S., and Amazon said ACR is off by default on Fire TV.
No company said users can opt out of all data transmission, since some data is needed for basic functions. The full company responses are summarized in The Verge’s report.

The Leak That Has No Off Switch
The study identified a separate issue on Vizio’s free WatchFree+ service, not a finding about every brand or streaming service. It puts the name of each show or channel into unencrypted web address lookups sent to Amagi, the company that delivers the streams.
That means someone on the network path, such as an internet provider, could rebuild an ordered list of what was watched. The researchers found no way to turn this off in the audited operating systems’ privacy policies or settings. Even a complete ACR opt-out would not stop this particular leak from Vizio’s tested service.
How To Talk To Your Child About The Television
Keep it simple and calm: “Some screens send information about what is playing so services can recommend shows or show ads. Let’s check what our TV shares.”
Explain that the point is not to make children anxious about watching a cartoon. It is to help them understand that an internet-connected screen can collect information, and that your family can review the settings together.
What The Law Says About Children’s Viewing Data
COPPA requires verifiable parental consent before a company collects personal information from a child under 13. That is why the researchers flagged tracking inside a kids’ app.
It remains an open question whether a fingerprint of a child’s cartoon counts as collecting a child’s information under the law. The study raises that question; it does not answer it or determine that any company violated COPPA.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Turning Off ACR Stop All TV Data Collection?
No. ACR is one type of tracking, and some settings may not cover the TV’s own streaming service. Basic functions may also require some data transmission. Disconnecting the TV from the internet stops transmission while it is offline.
Does The Study Show That Every Smart TV Tracks Children’s Shows?
No. It tested 12 TVs across eight operating systems. Researchers observed tracking in VIDAA Kids and found other differences by operating system, input and service. The findings apply to the devices and versions tested, not every TV model.
Is A TV’s Opt-Out Reliable?
It depends on the system and service. The study found that opting out fully worked on four tested systems, but results were mixed on Samsung and Vizio, and Roku’s setting did not cover its own streaming service.
Strengthen Your Family’s TV Privacy
You do not need to solve every privacy question in one sitting. Start with the tracking and voice settings, check which services your child actually uses, and decide whether the TV needs to be connected to the internet. A short family review can make a confusing setting easier to understand and support safer digital habits at home.
What TV privacy setting will you check first, or have you already found one that surprised you? Tell us in the comments.
Join the Secure Children’s Network newsletter for practical guidance on children’s digital well-being, privacy and emerging technology.
If this helped, share it with another parent and follow Secure Children's Network on Facebook, X and LinkedIn for safety alerts.
Author: Janice Robinson-Celeste
Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.